How It Works

We deliver traceable, sustainably sourced seafood to your doorstep, ensuring transparency while battling seafood fraud. Enjoy fresh, eco-friendly seafood delivered.
Discover Boxes

We make Seafood Simple

  • Swiming_fish_Char_05

    1. We Source the Best

    We partner with local fishermen and responsible land-farms in Iceland to deliver only top-quality seafood to your plate.
  • FishSkeptics_FamilySculpture_01

    2. You Choose

    We empower you to customize your seafood choices completely—it's all up to you.
  • ecom-edit-image4Al1L8bpkOBox_and_fish_Still_image_1

    3. We Deliver

    Our fast shipping process ensures your seafood arrives quickly and fully frozen, letting you enjoy top-quality fish right from home.

Why Track Seafood Origin?

By tracking, we confirm seafood origins, whether wild-caught or from land-based sustainable farms, guaranteeing quality and supporting conservation efforts.

See Tracking Information

Our Sustainable Seafood

FISH
Icelandic Salmon Box
FISH
Icelandic Cod Box
FISH
Icelandic Arctic Char Box
FISH
Custom Icelandic Seafood Box
FISH

Icelandic Salmon Box

Experience the superior taste and quality of our Icelandic Salmon, sustainably raised on land in Iceland. Each fillet is carefully nurtured in the best possible conditions, ensuring a premium product that is not only delicious but also environmentally friendly. Land raising is significantly better for ocean ecosystems, eliminating the negative impacts associated with sea farming.

  • One 6oz Portion Per Pack
  • Individually Vacuum Packed
  • Skin-On/Boneless
  • No Antibiotics nor GMO
  • FREE Illinois Shipping
FISH

Icelandic Cod Box

Experience the unmatched taste and quality of our wild-caught Icelandic cod, sustainably harvested from pristine ocean waters. Each fillet is meticulously processed to maintain its natural flavor and nutritional benefits, ensuring a product that is both delicious and environmentally friendly. Our sustainable fishing practices support healthy marine ecosystems and protect biodiversity.

  • One 6oz Portion Per Pack
  • Individually Vacuum Packed
  • Skin-On/Boneless
  • No Antibiotics nor GMO
  • FREE Illinois Shipping
FISH

Icelandic Arctic Char Box

Experience the exquisite taste and quality of our land-farmed Icelandic Arctic Char, sustainably raised in pristine conditions. Each fillet is meticulously processed to preserve its natural flavor and nutritional benefits, ensuring a product that is both delicious and environmentally friendly. Land farming is significantly better for ecosystems, eliminating the negative impacts associated with sea farming.

  • One 5oz Portion Per Pack
  • Individually Vacuum Packed
  • Skin-On/Boneless
  • No Antibiotics nor GMO
  • FREE Illinois Shipping
FISH

Custom Icelandic Seafood Box

Create your ideal seafood box with our Build-A-Box, featuring sustainably land-raised Icelandic Salmon, wild-caught Icelandic Cod, and sustainably land-raised Icelandic Arctic Char. Each fillet is processed for maximum flavor and nutritional benefits, ensuring a delicious and eco-friendly choice. Customize your box and enjoy premium quality seafood that supports sustainable practices.

  • 5/6oz Portions Per Pack
  • Individually Vacuum Packed
  • Skin-On/Boneless
  • No Antibiotics nor GMO
  • FREE Illinois Shipping

Icelandic Salmon Box

Experience the superior taste and quality of our Icelandic Salmon, sustainably raised on land in Iceland. Each fillet is carefully nurtured in the best possible conditions, ensuring a premium product that is not only delicious but also environmentally friendly. Land raising is significantly better for ocean ecosystems, eliminating the negative impacts associated with sea farming.

  • One 6oz Portion Per Pack
  • Individually Vacuum Packed
  • Skin-On/Boneless
  • No Antibiotics nor GMO
  • FREE Illinois Shipping

Fish For Skeptics has made me a believer in Fish, relying on their pink boxes delivering top-quality seafood, ensuring sustainability and unparalleled taste. Highly recommend for anyone seeking convenience and ethical seafood choices.

Duncan W

Verified Buyer

Shipping was fast, delivery was great and the fish was amazing, really good quality fish. Even though it took me a while to pick it up from my front desk, the fish was still fully frozen when I did.

Jose C

Verified Buyer

Icelandic Fish at its best! The individually portioned pieces make it convenient to prepare for individuals or larger groups alike. Despite the scorching summer heat, the fish was still completely frozen when it arrived at my door. I am impressed!

Katrin B

Verified Buyer

It has been a game-changer for me. Ethically sourced from Iceland, their fish arrives fresh and delicious at your doorstep. Every time. As a Minnesotan, I have always been skeptical of fish, especially good fish.

Jamieson W

Verified Buyer

I’m very impressed that Fish For Skeptics allows you to customize your order based on your specific fish quantity needs. What a luxury to have the convenience of getting Icelandic Arctic Char delivered directly to my doorstep. I can confidently say that Fish For Skeptics has become my top choice for purchasing fish.

Jens S

Verified Buyer

Our Story

"I had no way of knowing whether the seafood I was eating was really sustainably sourced. That's why I founded Fish For Skeptics."

Read Our Story

Eating Enough Seafood?

Most Americans don't eat enough seafood and worry about it's sustainability.
Eating seafood regularly provides essential nutrients like omega-3 fatty acids, vitamins, and minerals that are vital for good health. Incorporating a variety of seafood into your diet can help improve heart health, brain function, and overall well-being.
8oz

FDA Recommended amount of seafood consumed a week.

80%

Of Americans don't eat enough seafood.

57%

Have concerns about the sustainability of their seafood.